The following is the opinion and analysis of the writer:
I am an independent voter residing in Ward 2 who has lived and worked in 蜜柚直播 for 40 years. I have always loved living in 蜜柚直播 and usually support initiatives that seek to improve the lives of all 蜜柚直播ans including voting for tax increases. However, I cannot support Proposition 414.
While citizens across all socioeconomic levels would like to support public safety and many aspects of this ballot measure, the Mayor and Council have failed us in several ways. More specifically, when opportunities arise to raise revenue or reduce costs, they decline to act responsibly. Here are a few glaring examples:
Their decision to continue fare-free public transit costs the City nearly $10 million annually and corresponds with increased safety concerns from drivers and riders alike. It gives new meaning to the disclaimer 鈥淩ide at Your Own Risk鈥 as our buses have become a mobile refuge from the elements for drug users, the mentally ill and the homeless. This discourages other riders concerned for their safety.
People are also reading…
The City hired a consultant at $300,000 for an 鈥淓nergy Sourcing Study鈥 to investigate the feasibility of running its own public utility to replace TEP. This folly is right on the heels of spending $7 million unsuccessfully trying to become an Internet provider. The money that could have gone to public safety and affordable housing projects was squandered!
The City also spent more than $350,000 for consultants to unnecessarily 鈥渞eimagine鈥 Reid Park to create additional walking paths that damages the viability of two city-owned, revenue-generating public golf courses used by thousands.
Rather than making one-time investments or paying down debt, the City used COVID-era federal tax dollars to increase perpetual programs and staff when the funding was temporary and has now run out.
Unlike Pima County, the city refuses to take the simple step of installing educational signs at street corners to discourage panhandling. Instead, it continues to risk the safety of homeless and drug-impaired individuals occupying these corners, leaving them vulnerable to falling into traffic lanes, dying of exposure, or becoming victims of night-time traffic fatalities.
Lastly, I am reminded daily of the City鈥檚 abject failure to improve, maintain or repair even small sections of major arterial roads. Some examples include Grant, east of Columbus, Swan south of Grant, and numerous other streets.
The City faults declining state shared revenues and lower sales tax receipts, but if the City made its streets and neighborhood safer from crime, more businesses, retail stores, and restaurants would open or stay, thus increasing economic vitality and the tax base. Instead, law-abiding citizens incur a 鈥渃rime tax鈥 as businesses and residents alike are having to pay for glass replacement and increased security to protect their properties while the City turns a blind eye to lawlessness on our streets.
If Prop 414 passes, the City鈥檚 sales tax rate will be 9.2% versus 6.1% in Pima County. Therefore, on the purchase of a $25,000 used car, one would pay $775 more (3.1% more) in the City than the County. This is meaningful to most people, and it would hurt middle- and lower-income workers the most.
In summary, when many of us face declining income, we tighten our belts, make tough choices, and reprioritize. Instead, the City continues to spend recklessly and misses opportunities to grow revenues responsibly. With a $2.3 billion annual budget, representing a growth of 75% since 2015, it鈥檚 hard to believe that the City can鈥檛 find $80 million (3.47%) in its budget to first fund police and fire, and then allocate resources to other programs, without asking for more taxes from people that simply cannot afford it.
Vote no on Prop 414.
David Cohen is a certified public accountant who has advised businesses, non-profits and individuals for more than 40 years. As a University of 蜜柚直播 graduate and long-time 蜜柚直播an, he cares deeply about 蜜柚直播鈥檚 quality of place.