The following column is the opinion and analysis of the writer:
Actually, it鈥檚 Dr., not Mrs.
As a woman who earned her doctoral degree in Education Administration, I wasn鈥檛 surprised to read Joseph Epstein鈥檚 opinion piece about Jill Biden, published by the Wall Street Journal.
The fact that some people don鈥檛 understand that a doctorate is equal to a medical degree is lamentable, but not particularly newsworthy. The Journal chose to publish it because it expressed a view they thought their readers might consider interesting 鈥 as is their right.
What made the article the focus of my attention though, was the Journal鈥檚 defense of the article.
Had they stood by their own policy of publishing pieces that they think might be of interest to their subscribers, I might not like it very much but defend their right to publish opinions and face the consequences.
People are also reading…
That鈥檚 what a free press is all about. Controversy fires thought. And sells papers.
However, when in a separate editorial, editor Paul Gigot took offense at the reactions of his editorial peers, postulated Northwestern University鈥檚 decision to remove Epstein from their website was part of a larger 鈥渃ancel culture,鈥 and claimed the Biden team鈥檚 response was using it as 鈥渁 chance to use the big guns of identity politics to send a message to politics as it prepares to take office鈥 鈥 I took issue.
It鈥檚 one thing to neutrally publish an offensive opinion. It鈥檚 another to defend it.
This isn鈥檛 about identity politics, or the president taking office.
It鈥檚 about female identity.
The fact that a man with a bachelor鈥檚 degree feels comfortable disparaging a woman with a doctorate is an indication of just how far we still have to go.
But we, women, already knew that.
What we have not realized is the extent that men in positions of literary power are willing to go to hold the line
Instead of letting the chips, or words, fall where they may, the Journal鈥檚 editor has taken a giant step backward for equity and a stance against women.
I would like to imagine they are hearing the 鈥渃ancel my subscription鈥 links being clicked. But I suspect their readership is largely male and white.
I would like to think every man with a doctorate is appalled that his own degree is being trashed, and outraged by his female colleagues. But I suspect not. Privilege allows that momentary ire to pass quickly.
And I would like to wish every medical doctor might have time to speak loudly in defense of the lab researchers in the field. But they are too busy fighting a pandemic because no one believed in science, let alone a researcher with a 鈥渕ere鈥 doctorate in microbiology.
What I do know is this. Every woman that holds an advanced degree earned it. And deserves to be called 鈥淒octor.鈥
But writing a dissertation after work, typing with a toddler on her lap, while dinner is waiting, and Christmas gifts still need to be bought, isn鈥檛 the reason. The reason is, a doctor of any kind earns this small reward 鈥 and most especially a doctorate of education.
Workers in every other profession out there are inspired by an experience that inspired, encouraged and influenced their thinking.
It鈥檚 only because we have women (and men) who research how to perfect learning, improve education systems, or now, even keep kids learning while coping with a global pandemic, that we have doctors of any kind.
Or for that matter, journalists.
So let the op-eds flourish. But stop the defense of what many of us consider reprehensible. Be willing to face the consequences and judgment of your literary peers without blaming politics.
You can鈥檛 have it both ways.
If you have trouble understanding, perhaps Dr. Biden will teach you why.
Kathleen Bethel holds a doctorate in Education Administration and is the retired CEO of SARSEF 鈥 a science nonprofit, retired UA College of Engineering administrator and retired elementary principal.